I thought it was a reasonable theory

The nipple lady was in my office today. She was talking to someone else and that someone else called me over due to the nature of her request.

I asked what she was doing and if she had already had a meeting on it and she said that she had but I didn't recall it.

Later, I wanted to say "Yeah, now I remember. You're the one that I couldn't look at because you were a little nipple-ly that day."

And then, "How come only one of them popped?"

I told a co-worker the story on why I didn't recognize her and he said that the one that popped was the one that always gets teased.